Shop Rare Jellycat Tier List

Sponsored
$28.00
Jellycat Bashful Bunny Stuffed Animal In Medium Beige At Nordstrom
Nordstrom
$28.00
Jellycat Bashful Bunny Stuffed Animal In Medium Beige At Nordstrom
Nordstrom
$53.94
NWT Rare - Jellycat Campfire Limited Collection Cute Gift Sold Out
eBay.com
Free shipping
$53.94
NWT Rare - Jellycat Campfire Limited Collection Cute Gift Sold Out
eBay.com
$17.69
Jellycat Plush Toys Jellycat Stuffed Animals Monkey Plush Toy, Monkey Stuffed Animal Toys For 1 Year Old And Up, Best Gift For Kids Brown Jellycat Plu
Walmart
Free shipping
$17.69
Jellycat Plush Toys Jellycat Stuffed Animals Monkey Plush Toy, Monkey Stuffed Animal Toys For 1 Year Old And Up, Best Gift For Kids Brown Jellycat Plu
Walmart
$80.00
Jellycat Big Bashful Unicorn Stuffed Animal In White At Nordstrom
Nordstrom
$80.00
Jellycat Big Bashful Unicorn Stuffed Animal In White At Nordstrom
Nordstrom
$9.61
Yguo Jellycat, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Horse, Jellycat Pony Plush Toy - Fluffy & Soft Stuffed Animal Horse Doll 3
Walmart
$9.61
Yguo Jellycat, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Horse, Jellycat Pony Plush Toy - Fluffy & Soft Stuffed Animal Horse Doll 3
Walmart
$28.00
Jellycat Bashful Puppy Stuffed Animal In Black And Cream At Nordstrom
Nordstrom
$28.00
Jellycat Bashful Puppy Stuffed Animal In Black And Cream At Nordstrom
Nordstrom
$12.49
Yguo Jellycat, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Horse, Jellycat Pony Plush Toy - Large Stuffed Horse Doll, Soft Cuddly Plu
Walmart
$12.49
Yguo Jellycat, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Horse, Jellycat Pony Plush Toy - Large Stuffed Horse Doll, Soft Cuddly Plu
Walmart
$64.95
Retired Jellycat Bashful Viola Bunny Rare Purple Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal EUC
eBay.com
Free shipping
$64.95
Retired Jellycat Bashful Viola Bunny Rare Purple Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal EUC
eBay.com
$15.97
$37.19
Jellycat Blossom Blush Bunny 'Cherry' Plush - White, 12.20in
Walmart
Free shipping
57% off
$15.97
$37.19
Jellycat Blossom Blush Bunny 'Cherry' Plush - White, 12.20in
Walmart
$63.63
JELLYCAT Original Bashful Calf Cow Plush Spots Medium AUTHENTIC Rare BNWT
eBay.com
Free shipping
$63.63
JELLYCAT Original Bashful Calf Cow Plush Spots Medium AUTHENTIC Rare BNWT
eBay.com
$79.99
RARE Jellycat Bashful Raccoon Medium 12" Retired Plush
eBay.com
Free shipping
$79.99
RARE Jellycat Bashful Raccoon Medium 12" Retired Plush
eBay.com
$16.99
Jellycat Stuffed Animals Animals Series, Jellycat Kitten Stuffed Animal Jellycat Plush Jelly Cats Stuffed Animals Kitten Plush Toy 11 Inch, Plushies F
Walmart
$16.99
Jellycat Stuffed Animals Animals Series, Jellycat Kitten Stuffed Animal Jellycat Plush Jelly Cats Stuffed Animals Kitten Plush Toy 11 Inch, Plushies F
Walmart
$11.70
Yguo Amazon Jellycat - Jelly Cat - White Bunny Jellycat - Jellycat Rabbit - Jellycat Floral Bunny Plush - Snuggly & Fluffy Stuffed Rabbit Doll 40cm -
Walmart
$11.70
Yguo Amazon Jellycat - Jelly Cat - White Bunny Jellycat - Jellycat Rabbit - Jellycat Floral Bunny Plush - Snuggly & Fluffy Stuffed Rabbit Doll 40cm -
Walmart
$86.00
Jellycat Bashful Luxe Bunny Curly RARE Limited Collection BNWT Medium
eBay.com
Free shipping
$86.00
Jellycat Bashful Luxe Bunny Curly RARE Limited Collection BNWT Medium
eBay.com
$45.45
Rare Jellycat Beebi Pup Soft Plush 11" Mauve/White Puppy Dog Pellet Bottom Toy
eBay.com
Free shipping
$45.45
Rare Jellycat Beebi Pup Soft Plush 11" Mauve/White Puppy Dog Pellet Bottom Toy
eBay.com
$55.00
Jellycat Rumpletum Dino Rare Retired Plush Green Dinosaur HTF
eBay.com
Free shipping
$55.00
Jellycat Rumpletum Dino Rare Retired Plush Green Dinosaur HTF
eBay.com
$74.99
Jellycat Rare HTF Tessa Bashful 12" Bunny Flower Floral Ears Feet Plush
eBay.com
Free shipping
$74.99
Jellycat Rare HTF Tessa Bashful 12" Bunny Flower Floral Ears Feet Plush
eBay.com
$64.99
Jellycat Small BASHFUL GOLDEN BUNNY 7" Soft Plush Toy RETIRED & RARE Lovey NWT
eBay.com
Free shipping
$64.99
Jellycat Small BASHFUL GOLDEN BUNNY 7" Soft Plush Toy RETIRED & RARE Lovey NWT
eBay.com
$82.00
Jellycat Rose Petalkin Doll BNWT Retired Rare HTF Fairy Fairytale Cute Fast Ship
eBay.com
Free shipping
$82.00
Jellycat Rose Petalkin Doll BNWT Retired Rare HTF Fairy Fairytale Cute Fast Ship
eBay.com
$69.95
New With Tags Jellycat Gibbles Monster Dark Purple Retired Rare Plush
eBay.com
Free shipping
$69.95
New With Tags Jellycat Gibbles Monster Dark Purple Retired Rare Plush
eBay.com
$59.77
Jellycat CAREY CALF Soft Plush Toy RARE Retired Stuffed Animal Cow Lovey
eBay.com
Free shipping
$59.77
Jellycat CAREY CALF Soft Plush Toy RARE Retired Stuffed Animal Cow Lovey
eBay.com
$64.95
Jellycat Original Bashful Blush Bunny Medium-RARE-Nwtags&Protector-Fast Shipping
eBay.com
Free shipping
$64.95
Jellycat Original Bashful Blush Bunny Medium-RARE-Nwtags&Protector-Fast Shipping
eBay.com
$30.00
Jellycat Frizzles Tortoise Turtle Plush Green Retired 6" Rare Htf
eBay.com
Free shipping
$30.00
Jellycat Frizzles Tortoise Turtle Plush Green Retired 6" Rare Htf
eBay.com
$45.00
Jellycat Dog Plush Pug Suede Rare Hard To Find Retired Pablo Medium 10" HTF
eBay.com
Free shipping
$45.00
Jellycat Dog Plush Pug Suede Rare Hard To Find Retired Pablo Medium 10" HTF
eBay.com
$64.99
Jellycat London CAREY CALF 7" Soft Plush Toy RARE RETIRED Authentic Farm Cow
eBay.com
Free shipping
$64.99
Jellycat London CAREY CALF 7" Soft Plush Toy RARE RETIRED Authentic Farm Cow
eBay.com
$34.25
Jellycat Little Horse -Cute Stuffed Animal RARE-Nwtag & Protector- Fast Shipping
eBay.com
Free shipping
$34.25
Jellycat Little Horse -Cute Stuffed Animal RARE-Nwtag & Protector- Fast Shipping
eBay.com
$59.00
Jellycat Tumblie Duck EUC Rare Retired Plush Toy Floopy Display Cute
eBay.com
Free shipping
$59.00
Jellycat Tumblie Duck EUC Rare Retired Plush Toy Floopy Display Cute
eBay.com
$48.00
Jellycat Original
Julien's a Lifestyle Store
$48.00
Jellycat Original
Julien's a Lifestyle Store
$49.99
Jellycat Medium Bashful Chocolate Bunny Plush Rabbit Dark Brown Retired Rare
eBay.com
Free shipping
$49.99
Jellycat Medium Bashful Chocolate Bunny Plush Rabbit Dark Brown Retired Rare
eBay.com
$55.00
Jellycat Delia Duck BNWT Easter Plush Lovely Rare Fast Shipping
eBay.com
Free shipping
$55.00
Jellycat Delia Duck BNWT Easter Plush Lovely Rare Fast Shipping
eBay.com
$39.99
Jellycat Dozydou Blue Donkey Floppy Beanbag Plush 12" Rare HTF
eBay.com
$39.99
Jellycat Dozydou Blue Donkey Floppy Beanbag Plush 12" Rare HTF
eBay.com
$99.99
Jellycat BARN OWLING Soft Plush Toy NWT Rare Stuffed Bird Collectible Barn Farm
eBay.com
Free shipping
$99.99
Jellycat BARN OWLING Soft Plush Toy NWT Rare Stuffed Bird Collectible Barn Farm
eBay.com
$24.03
Yguo Bashful Jellycat, Smudge Bunny Jellycat, Small Jellycat, Jellycat Bunny Small, Jellycat Floral Bunny Plush - Extra Large Long-Eared Stuffed Bunny
Walmart
$24.03
Yguo Bashful Jellycat, Smudge Bunny Jellycat, Small Jellycat, Jellycat Bunny Small, Jellycat Floral Bunny Plush - Extra Large Long-Eared Stuffed Bunny
Walmart
$49.99
Jellycat Minikin Fawn Stuffed Toy Plush Rare
eBay.com
Free shipping
$49.99
Jellycat Minikin Fawn Stuffed Toy Plush Rare
eBay.com
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop Rare Jellycat Tier List

    Sponsored
    $28.00
    Jellycat Bashful Bunny Stuffed Animal In Medium Beige At Nordstrom
    Nordstrom
    $28.00
    Jellycat Bashful Bunny Stuffed Animal In Medium Beige At Nordstrom
    Nordstrom
    $53.94
    NWT Rare - Jellycat Campfire Limited Collection Cute Gift Sold Out
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $53.94
    NWT Rare - Jellycat Campfire Limited Collection Cute Gift Sold Out
    eBay.com
    $17.69
    Jellycat Plush Toys Jellycat Stuffed Animals Monkey Plush Toy, Monkey Stuffed Animal Toys For 1 Year Old And Up, Best Gift For Kids Brown Jellycat Plu
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $17.69
    Jellycat Plush Toys Jellycat Stuffed Animals Monkey Plush Toy, Monkey Stuffed Animal Toys For 1 Year Old And Up, Best Gift For Kids Brown Jellycat Plu
    Walmart
    $80.00
    Jellycat Big Bashful Unicorn Stuffed Animal In White At Nordstrom
    Nordstrom
    $80.00
    Jellycat Big Bashful Unicorn Stuffed Animal In White At Nordstrom
    Nordstrom
    $9.61
    Yguo Jellycat, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Horse, Jellycat Pony Plush Toy - Fluffy & Soft Stuffed Animal Horse Doll 3
    Walmart
    $9.61
    Yguo Jellycat, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Horse, Jellycat Pony Plush Toy - Fluffy & Soft Stuffed Animal Horse Doll 3
    Walmart
    $28.00
    Jellycat Bashful Puppy Stuffed Animal In Black And Cream At Nordstrom
    Nordstrom
    $28.00
    Jellycat Bashful Puppy Stuffed Animal In Black And Cream At Nordstrom
    Nordstrom
    $12.49
    Yguo Jellycat, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Horse, Jellycat Pony Plush Toy - Large Stuffed Horse Doll, Soft Cuddly Plu
    Walmart
    $12.49
    Yguo Jellycat, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Stuffed Animals, Jellycat Horse, Jellycat Pony Plush Toy - Large Stuffed Horse Doll, Soft Cuddly Plu
    Walmart
    $64.95
    Retired Jellycat Bashful Viola Bunny Rare Purple Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal EUC
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $64.95
    Retired Jellycat Bashful Viola Bunny Rare Purple Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal EUC
    eBay.com
    $15.97
    $37.19
    Jellycat Blossom Blush Bunny 'Cherry' Plush - White, 12.20in
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    57% off
    $15.97
    $37.19
    Jellycat Blossom Blush Bunny 'Cherry' Plush - White, 12.20in
    Walmart
    $63.63
    JELLYCAT Original Bashful Calf Cow Plush Spots Medium AUTHENTIC Rare BNWT
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $63.63
    JELLYCAT Original Bashful Calf Cow Plush Spots Medium AUTHENTIC Rare BNWT
    eBay.com
    $79.99
    RARE Jellycat Bashful Raccoon Medium 12" Retired Plush
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $79.99
    RARE Jellycat Bashful Raccoon Medium 12" Retired Plush
    eBay.com
    $16.99
    Jellycat Stuffed Animals Animals Series, Jellycat Kitten Stuffed Animal Jellycat Plush Jelly Cats Stuffed Animals Kitten Plush Toy 11 Inch, Plushies F
    Walmart
    $16.99
    Jellycat Stuffed Animals Animals Series, Jellycat Kitten Stuffed Animal Jellycat Plush Jelly Cats Stuffed Animals Kitten Plush Toy 11 Inch, Plushies F
    Walmart
    $11.70
    Yguo Amazon Jellycat - Jelly Cat - White Bunny Jellycat - Jellycat Rabbit - Jellycat Floral Bunny Plush - Snuggly & Fluffy Stuffed Rabbit Doll 40cm -
    Walmart
    $11.70
    Yguo Amazon Jellycat - Jelly Cat - White Bunny Jellycat - Jellycat Rabbit - Jellycat Floral Bunny Plush - Snuggly & Fluffy Stuffed Rabbit Doll 40cm -
    Walmart
    $86.00
    Jellycat Bashful Luxe Bunny Curly RARE Limited Collection BNWT Medium
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $86.00
    Jellycat Bashful Luxe Bunny Curly RARE Limited Collection BNWT Medium
    eBay.com
    $45.45
    Rare Jellycat Beebi Pup Soft Plush 11" Mauve/White Puppy Dog Pellet Bottom Toy
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $45.45
    Rare Jellycat Beebi Pup Soft Plush 11" Mauve/White Puppy Dog Pellet Bottom Toy
    eBay.com
    $55.00
    Jellycat Rumpletum Dino Rare Retired Plush Green Dinosaur HTF
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $55.00
    Jellycat Rumpletum Dino Rare Retired Plush Green Dinosaur HTF
    eBay.com
    $74.99
    Jellycat Rare HTF Tessa Bashful 12" Bunny Flower Floral Ears Feet Plush
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $74.99
    Jellycat Rare HTF Tessa Bashful 12" Bunny Flower Floral Ears Feet Plush
    eBay.com
    $64.99
    Jellycat Small BASHFUL GOLDEN BUNNY 7" Soft Plush Toy RETIRED & RARE Lovey NWT
    eBay.com
    Free shipping
    $64.99
    Jellycat Small BASHFUL GOLDEN BUNNY 7" Soft Plush Toy RETIRED & RARE Lovey NWT
    eBay.com